What Is a Contingency Agreement in Roofing (and Why You Should Avoid Contractors Who Require One)

When your roof is damaged by hail, wind, or storms, most homeowners start searching for a trusted roofing contractor. In that process, you may be asked to sign a contingency agreement—but what exactly is it, and why should you think twice before signing one?

What Is a Contingency Agreement?

A contingency agreement is a contract some roofing contractors use during the insurance claims process. It typically states that if your insurance company approves your roof replacement or repair, you are legally bound to hire that specific contractor to do the work.

In other words: by signing, you’re committing to use that contractor no matter what—even before you know their pricing, workmanship quality, or whether they’re the right fit for your home.

Why Some Contractors Push Contingency Agreements

Contractors who rely on contingency agreements often do so for one reason: to lock you in as a customer. From their perspective, it eliminates the risk that you’ll shop around once your claim is approved.

While this protects the contractor, it doesn’t necessarily protect you, the homeowner.

The Risks for Homeowners

Signing a contingency agreement can create several problems:

• Loss of Flexibility – You lose the ability to compare bids or choose another roofer later.
• Potential for Overpayment – Without competition, some contractors may inflate pricing or cut corners.
• Commitment Without Proof – You’re legally bound before seeing the contractor’s track record or warranties in action.
• Insurance Conflicts – Some agreements may interfere with your ability to negotiate with your insurance company.

In short, contingency agreements often shift control away from the homeowner—and into the contractor’s hands.

Why You Should Choose a Contractor Who Doesn’t Require One

The best roofing contractors don’t need a contingency agreement to earn your trust. Instead, they build confidence by offering:

• Transparent Estimates – Clear, detailed pricing before you commit.
• Proof of Workmanship – Photos, reviews, and references that show quality results.
• Insurance Expertise – Guidance through the claims process without locking you into a contract.
• Flexible Options – Freedom to compare, choose, and decide on your own timeline.

When you choose a contractor who doesn’t require a contingency agreement, you remain in control. You can make your decision based on trust, reputation, and value—not pressure.

Final Thoughts

A roofing project is one of the most important investments you’ll make in your home. Don’t give up your decision-making power by signing a contract too early.

Instead, look for a licensed, insured, and transparent roofing contractor who provides guidance without strings attached. The right roofer will earn your business with professionalism and results—not a piece of paper.

‍